The Pros and Cons of Each Disney World Resort

There are dozens of resorts at Disney World, and it can be overwhelming to choose where to stay. Here are the pros and cons of each Disney-owned resort on the property!

Now that I have stayed at every Walt Disney World resort, I’m ready to share which ones I love and the ones I could live without at each resort! One of my personal favorite parts to any Disney World vacation is the resort!

When my son was little, he was the same way. He always wanted to spend more time at the “zort“. We like to take a mid-day break because we get hot and tired, so in the summer we prefer to stay at a deluxe or moderate resort because they have great pools and are easier to get to.

In the winter, I’ll stay wherever! I did a post a while back on the differences between value, moderate, and deluxe resorts. Honestly, I think they all have their charms! Let’s first take a look at the value category!

Value

There are three resorts in the value category: Pop Century, Art of Animation, and All Star Resort. The All Stars are comprised of the All Star Movies, All Star Music, and All Star Sports.

Pop Century

One of the main pros for Disney’s Pop Century Resort is the proximity to the Skyliner transportation. Even aside from the skyliner, the resort is in a decent location. I like the remodeled rooms (identical to all star movies rooms), and the theme is fun and nostalgic!

A con would be the food court. When I stayed here in May, I had trouble finding something to eat since I’m particular. The subpar green beans are a running gag in our writer’s chat. Just not the best.

Art of Animation

Disney’s Art of Animation has plenty of positives too! Since the resort is built on property initially meant for a Pop Century expansion, the two resorts share a Skyliner station!

I love the statues at this value resort in particular. Any “Cars” fan NEEDS to visit this resort at night and see the cars section! Amazing.

As for cons, I find the suites at Art of Animation to be too expensive. They usually cost as much as a deluxe resort room. The standard Little Mermaid Rooms are far away from the main building and bus stop.

I also can not stand the music they play at the food court. Think of it as mediocre poppy renditions of your childhood favorites. I shudder just thinking about the Part of Your World cover.

Disney’s All Star Resort

I did a video review of All Star Movies Resort after the remodel. Love the rooms, love the statues, and they always have great service! Movies is, right now, the cheapest Disney World resort to stay at!

I’d say a major con would be the transportation. Value resorts wear me out with the whole standing in line in the sun to board a bus to the parks! All Star Resorts are near Disney’s Animal Kingdom theme park, which means it’s kind of far from Epcot and Magic Kingdom parks.

Moderate

For just a little more per night (ok as much as twice the price per night!), you can stay at one of Disney’s moderate resorts.

Coronado Springs Resort

The other writers often make fun of how many Coronado Springs stays I have booked! Even though our “home“ resort is Boulder Ridge at Disney’s Wilderness Lodge, we still feel at home at CSR.

Specifically we love the new Gran Destino Tower! Its very nice for the price, and it feels like you’re getting a deluxe for the cost of a moderate.

Coronado Springs has yummy food options, an awesome pool, and the largest hot tub on Disney property!

See why I book it all the time? I always book it first because I find no matter the season, the tower is reasonably priced.

As for cons, the resort fits a lot of people and has multiple bus stops. Occasionally we have to wait for the next bus from Gran Destino because it’s the last bus stop and the bus is already full.

An additional con would be that the restaurants (including the quick service) aren’t owned and operated by Disney. Recently, we haven’t been able to get a fountain Coke at the food court. It’s all grab and go stuff. Not a big deal but not what frequent Disney guests are used to.

Finally, the elevators can take quite a while to arrive at each floor! The line moves fast, but still, when you’re back from a day at the parks and just want to go to the room, it’s frustrating.

Caribbean Beach Resort

I have not stayed at Disney’s Caribbean Beach Resort since the big remodel when Riviera was built next door. But when I stopped at the Skyliner station, I saw how convenient it would be to stay here and it’s now back on my list!

A con would be that the pirate rooms are so cute but only have full sized beds. I don’t like paying moderate prices for double beds, especially now that the value resorts have queens.

The Cabins at Fort Wilderness

Fort Wilderness pros include seeing Halloween and Christmas decorations, visiting Hoop Dee Doo Musical Revue and visiting Chip n Dale’s Campfire Sing-along. Other pros to this resort include more recreation than most resorts with the Tri Circle D Ranch, archery, fishing, and so forth!

As for a con, is it is so spread out. I don’t want to take an internal resort shuttle to get to quick service. I feel like it’s necessary to have a golf cart to stay here, but by the time I add the price of a golf cart to the room rate, I may as well go deluxe.

Deluxe

Disney fans love the Deluxe resorts! Rather than going heavy on Disney theming, they go all in on making you feel like you’re somewhere else entirely! If you’re looking to stay as close to the magic as possible, deluxe resorts are for you!

Please note: where appropriate, I am lumping a Deluxe and their DVC counterpart(s) together. Some of the main resorts below have yet to reopen, but their DVC rooms are open!

Disney’s Contemporary Resort/ Bay Lake Tower

My family and I love to stay at Disney’s Contemporary resort. We love dining at Steakhouse 71, the views and the nostalgic feel. The Contemporary is my favorite resort for shopping, too!

You can’t beat the Contemporary for views of the Magic Kingdom and walking distance to the park. Usually, you can also monorail to Epcot (or Magic Kingdom).

So, good food, great location, magical feeling, shopping, check. However, I feel the pool is a little lackluster. I prefer to book Bay Lake Tower for access to their pool if I am visiting during the hot months.

It’s also a little like Tomorrowland in that it feels like what people thought the future would look like in the 1970s. The rooms were remodeled a couple of years ago to the Incredibles theme!

Disney’s Polynesian Resort/ Disney’s Polynesian Villas and Bungalows

I once compared the Polynesian to the Yacht club. Although I slightly preferred the Yacht Club, the Polynesian has a lot going for it! The theming, location, food, and transportation (I prefer the boat!) can’t be beaten. The Polynesian is consistently the favorite resort among Disney guests, and it’s easy to see why.

The first time I visited the Polynesian for dinner there was a big storm and I felt like we were in the Pacific islands! The Polynesian makes guests feel like they’re somewhere else entirely!

As for cons, I felt that the rooms desperately needed a remodel! I got my wish as the resort received a new Moana themed room! Check out construction progress here.

One other thing that kind of bugs me is that the resort is always swarming with people! I get it, I love to visit it too!

(The Villas at) Disney’s Grand Floridian Resort and Spa

The Grand Floridian, like its other monorail friends, has great dining, shopping and transportation! Now, you can even walk to the Magic Kingdom! That’s an awesome benefit and you can take a little boat or monorail as well!

As for cons, I would say this resort also tends to have a lot of people coming and going. I also feel like some of the guests and Cast Members are a little stuffy or uppity.

Disney’s Wilderness Lodge/ Copper Creek Villas and Cabins/ Boulder Ridge Villas

We love the Wilderness Lodge! The boat transportation, the lobby, and the pool are all great! I hadn’t mentioned the Electric Water Pageant before, but all of the Magic Kingdom area resorts have it and we love it!

I am not thrilled with the restaurants there, although it’s nice to eat at the outdoor quick service/bar hybrid, Geyser Point. During normal times, we loved that you could take a boat to the Contemporary or Fort Wilderness for more dining options.

I’d say about the only con is that the rooms are a little dark. They are being remodeled, and they look a bit brighter to me!

Yacht and Beach Club/ Beach Club Villas

As I previously mentioned, Yacht Club is one of our favorite deluxe resorts! A pro for this resort is the location: quick walk to Epcot, a boat to Hollywood (or walk!), you can make the short walk to Epcot and use the Skyliner to get to Disney’s Hollywood Studios as well. The Yacht and Beach Club Resort offers easy access to the Boardwalk, Swan and Dolphin, and Fantasia Gardens Mini Golf.

Then there’s the amazing pool area! Who doesn’t love a lazy river? The rooms at the Yacht Club have been renovated fairly recently, and I love the decor! The curtains alone are to die for.

Possible downsides to these resorts: some guests feel the Yacht Club is a bit stuffy.

I’ve heard parents with young children (or multiple children) don’t love the pool area because it’s so big and there are deep portions. You must leave the gated pool area to access the slide or to find a men’s restroom.

The shopping is also a bit limited at the Yacht Club and Beach Club stores, when compared to other deluxe resorts.

Boardwalk Inn / Disney’s Boardwalk Villas

Disney’s Boardwalk Inn and the Boardwalk Villas share the awesome location title with nearby Yacht and Beach Club! Walking to Epcot and Hollywood is great!

I have yet to stay at the Boardwalk Inn, but I’ve heard from friends how much they like this quiet, unassuming resort.

With a new facade for the pool, Disney Imagineering ditched the creepy clown in favor of a Mickey Mouse theme! RIP Spaghettios Clown!

Who can forget the misspelling incident? Hey, its not like Keister is a word you use everyday!

There is no quick service or drink refill station in the Boardwalk Resort. While it’s not a big deal, one must head out to the Boardwalk itself for eats or walk over to the Beach Club Resort. Just a mild inconvenience.

Disney’s Riviera Resort

Disney’s newest resort has so much going for it! It’s really nice, on the skyliner and has delicious food options! I love Primo Piatto and Topolinos, and I don’t usually get excited about the food at Disney. Bar Riva is a great place to unwind after a long day.

The Riviera Resort is all Disney Vacation Club style villas. We have reviews of rooms and the resort itself! Check out our review of the tower suite here.

This is another one that I haven’t had a chance to enjoy as an overnight guest, so it’s tough to think about cons. It’s pretty expensive compared to similar lodging at Disney, usually about twice the price of a room at my trusty Gran Destino Tower.

Animal Kingdom Lodge/ Kidani Village/ Jambo House

The Animal Kingdom Lodge impresses and stuns from the moment one sets foot in the lobby. It’s positively gorgeous and luxurious, before you even make your way to the savannah!

The food options normally can’t be beat, but currently two favorite restaurants are closed, Boma and Jiko. You can still eat at Sanaa.

Having stayed at the lodge a few times, the location is a bit of a turn off. We are used to being places quickly and Animal Kingdom Park is the only park that’s a quick ride from the lodge. You must take a bus to get to every resort, which can be a bit of a drag waiting around for the next bus.

I’ve never had any lunch or dinner food that I would order again at the Mara Quick Service either. Pretty mediocre and I detest the music that they play. I get it, it sets the mood, but it just bugs me and I can’t help it!

Saratoga Springs Resort and Spa

My family has stayed at the Saratoga Springs resort many times! My in-laws own a DVC membership there and graciously put us up every other year or so. If you spend a lot of time at Disney Springs, you’ll love the proximity from this resort. It’s also a pretty quick ride to anywhere else in Disney World, once your bus leaves the resort.

The Turf Club and the Artist’s Palette are better than expected. There are two feature pools with slides! The (all DVC) rooms have been recently fully remodeled! This is by far the quietest resort I’ve ever stayed at.

Cons for Saratoga would mainly center around the size of the resort itself. There are 5 bus stops and it can take a while to get out of the resort once picked up.

I’ve stayed in rooms where I felt the walk was way too far to get to the quick service.

Old Key West

Old Key West is the oldest Disney Vacation Club Resort and it is HUGE. We have a review of a 2 bedroom suite for you to check out!

Like Saratoga Springs and Riviera Resort, all the rooms at Old Key West are Disney Vacation Club villas. They can all be booked by any guest on the Disney website!

The studio villas at Old Key West have a unique feature: 2 queen beds! The other DVC studios have either a queen bed and a sofa bed or a queen bed and a Murphy bed! Olivia’s breakfast is on my must-do list!

As for cons, some of the buildings do not have elevators! Make sure to take care when booking if you have someone in your party with mobility issues.

Final Thoughts

So, I’ll tell you my top 3 resorts based on everything above. For value, I choose All Star Movies, mostly because I’ve made some great memories there. Obviously for moderate my choice is Coronado Springs, specifically the Gran Destino Tower. Finally, for deluxe, it’s a really tough choice between Yacht Club and Disney’s Wilderness Lodge. I think Wilderness has a slight edge for me again for nostalgia and having stayed there so many times!

So, the top 5 resorts are: Coronado, Wilderness, Yacht and Beach Club, Contemporary and All Star Movies.

What do you make of my assessment? What are your top 3 resorts? Let us know in the comments below!